Site Map: MAIN / A Reader's Treasury / This Page
A READER'S TREASURY
Magic in Action
Published by Meta Publications in 1984
Book Review by Bobby Matherne ©2001
Like Us? Subscribe to Receive a Monthly Email
Reminder of New Reviews & New DIGESTWORLD Issues ó CLICK
This is a book of a transcript of Richard Bandler working with several different clients. It has been transcribed from a video tape. If youíve ever cooked a complicated dish, you know how important every aspect of your senses are during the preparation of the dish. Your feeling for the temperature of the food in the pot at each stage of cooking, the smells that come out of the pot during each stage, the texture of the food as it cooks down, the sound of the onions as they sautť, the color and the translucency of the onions as they cook, the taste of the dish as it nears completion Ė attending to all these in their exquisite detail makes the difference between a great-tasting dish or a flop. Now look at the recipe for the same dish: all black and white on paper, quantities, and instructions. No matter how complicated the instructions, the proof is in the cooking. Reading this book of Bandler doing therapy is like reading those complicated instructions. The tone, timbre, rhythm, inflection, and quality of his voice are all flattened out, so most if not all of his tonal anchors are not available to the reader. (These are usually missed anyway by others, as Bandler has pointed out on many occasions.) What the client is doing while Bandler is speaking is completely deleted because only the words of the person speaking is transcribed.
Given all these limitations, itís a wonder why anyone would try to transcribe Bandlerís work at all. Or buy the book of such a transcription. I wonder why I did it some sixteen years ago myself. Maybe I didnít understand then the things Iím describing to you now, dear reader. So donít expect this to be a ďGee, youíre wonderful, Mr. Bandler.Ē homage thing. Instead Iíll try to cook up a few interesting side dishes to accompany your reading of the main course, the book, just in case, in spite of my suggestions to the contrary, you decide to read it, instead of view the video tape or better yet, schedule a live seminar with Bandler.
As I wrote in the margin of page 21 on August 24, 1985, ďI donít consider myself a therapist, but an entertainer of options.Ē You might wish to do the same, if you have enough options; if not, get some more. About eight pages later I wrote, ďIn the mirror I see the reflection of all my thoughts.Ē Put the book down and go look at the reflection of all your thoughts in the mirror. Itís what other people see all the time anyway, you might as well look for yourself.
In the book, Bandler deals with the following topics in seven chapters: Anticipatory Loss, Agoraphobia, Fear of Authority Figures, Worms, Chocolate, Beyond Beliefs I&II. The best advice I ever heard Bandler give about anticipatory loss was when he said, ďYou have to plan ahead to be disappointed.Ē People who are disappointed by life have a process for preparing themselves in a way that results in feeling what they call disappointment later. Break that process and their disappointment never arises. I knew a therapist who used to tell me, ďI donít fix people, I break them.Ē What he meant was that people have processes that work well to create unwanted things all the time; he saw his job as identifying those processes and breaking them so that the person has more time and energy to spend doing wanted things.
Agoraphobics are like oysters: they want to stay in their shells all the time, however they define their shell. In the case of Bandlerís client, he wanted to stay within the city: that was his oyster. Why do I say they are like oysters? Have you ever eaten a live oyster? Donít know? Well, the answer is no, because the oyster dies when the large muscle that holds the shell closed is cut during the opening of the oyster. How do you know if oyster was alive before you opened it? Easy, your nose will tell you very quickly; besides the shell will already be open with no muscle to hold it shut.
Yes, agoraphobics are like oysters: their life depends on their holding their shells shut, and the therapist is like the oyster man with his blade-opener. The harder he presses his blade between the crack in the shells to separate the two shells, the harder the oyster bears down with its muscle. Finally the shells are parted, the muscle separated and the oyster is ready to eat. The agoraphobic thinks he will die if he leaves the shell of his city, and he holds with all his might against the blade of the therapist who open him up to entertaining other options. To open up an agoraphobic is as difficult as opening an oyster, with the added challenge of keeping the agoraphobic alive, because after all, it is living that frightens the agoraphobic, rightly understood.
In dealing with authority figures, Bandler is at his playful best. I will put the strongest tonal anchor in italics in the passage below, something the transcribers for the book didnít think was necessary. There are eleven more tonal anchors in this short sequence, as you can find by inspection.
[page 83] Close your eyes. Begin to run through different times and places and memories. Between each one go back to the one that gave you this feeling. Exhilarated plus. Thatís right. Keep this with you. Should take that everywhere you go. makes your skin glow pretty. Youíve got some playful parts in there. I can see. They sneak out when you drink donít they?
In dealing with Anita with her phobia of worms, Bandler spends a lot of time illustrating how to evoke phobias in order to cure them. He talks about the snake episode in Raiders of the Lost Ark when Indiana Jones looks down and says, ďIt had to be snakes!Ē and Bandler says for her it ďhad to be worms.Ē All the while heís talking about snakes, sheís thinking worms. ďAttack of the Killer Worms.Ē Heís getting Anita to entertain the option of laughing when she thinks of worms instead of cringing as sheís done every time, up until now.
Humor is an essential part of Bandlerís work and one of the benefits of having his live work flattened out in a book is that when youíre in a session with him, you tend to go from one laugh to another and ignore the essential nature of the therapeutic move contained in the item that created the laugh. Hereís a test Ė see if you can spot the laugh line in the following passage from the Chocolate chapter. [Iíll put the key word in italics so itíll jump out at you and form a vivid, full picture in your mind when you read it.] He just asked Eileen why not eat chocolate all the time, and she said because it would make her sick:[page 125] Thatís true, it would make you sick. Is there any other reason? Why would you want to diminish your enjoyment of, or your pleasure and attraction to chocolate? Weíll wait here for a few minutes . . . for you to figure out a good reason. (Laughter)
Well, dear reader, were you able to figure it out? Some say it takes will power to control an addiction to chocolate, others say it takes wonít power. The function of the will is one that is often ignored by so-called modern people who think it as an old-fashioned term, but rightly understood, the will is an important aspect of what it means to be human. It distinguishes us from animals who donít have will power Ė they act just like animals, donít they? Hereís a passage in which Bandler gives us insight on what I would call will:[page 143] I believe that anything that you have to struggle to do is based on not having yourself organized internally in advance.
Isnít that a beautiful way of thinking about will: having yourself internally organized in advance so that what you want do is a natural action determined from within by none other than you! An entertaining prospect, isnít it? Ending a statement with tags lines are fun, arenít they? ďIsnít it?Ē and ďArenít they?Ē are tag lines, am I not right about that?
At one point, he pretends not to remember the name of the process of reframing and lets the man provide the word. Richard Bandler feeds him the clue by saying ďumm . . . re something or the other?Ē [italics added . . . must have been a shortage of italics type when they typeset this book.][page 193]
Man ~~~~~~~ Reblaming?
Richard ~~~~ Yes. Reblaming, thatís what it was. (Laughter). Thatís where if itís not ecological you blame someone else in your family. (Laughter).
Humor and quickness Ė two words that describe Bandler. He does the therapy in seconds, but indulges himself for minutes so that he can charge for the session, so that he charge up the therapists, charging them up to get them to move out of their pearl-lined shells into another and more fun-filled world. Hereís another example of his humor and quickness:[page 162] (Laughter) Well that takes care of that. Another sixty seconds of therapy. If you know what youíre doing, therapy doesnít take that long.
As I like to say, "He who laughs, lasts." And thatís an important thing about entertaining a new option: making it last. Iíve noticed that all therapists worry themselves about that Ė what if it lasts forever and my clients never come back? Not to worry, Bandler tells them:[page 200] But the intricacies and the delicacies of being able to find out which elements to work with specifically to get lasting results, thatís where the real artistry comes from.
One never knew what was real or not with Bandler. Hereís an example. Read it and you tell me if he actually did what he describes below:[page 201] I used to run a seminar called the Fabric of Reality. We all got together and methodically dissected our ability to discern what was real and what was not real. Thatís why none of those people are here anymore. (Laughter).
Bandler loved to shoot therapists down; thatís why he filled his seminars and taped presentations like this one with therapists. He saw them like stiff, upright bowling pins, all lined up according to the rules of their particular bowling association. By end of a presentation he had them rolling on the floor like bowling pins after a strike. So, in closing, itís only right to let Bandler show us his ďmagic in action," and have the last laugh, er, word:[page 203) Thatís why I always loved bowling, except for the part of picking up the heavy ball. (Laughter). You know, I always wanted to shoot the pins down. That seemed a lot easier to me. (Laughter).---------------------------- Reference Links for Bandler and Grinder ---------------
Any questions about this review, Contact: Bobby Matherne
Click Left Photo for List of All ARJ2 Reviews Click Right Bookcover for Next Review in ListDid you Enjoy this Webpage?
Subscribe to the Good Mountain Press Digest: Click Here!
CLICK ON FLAGS TO OPEN OUR FIRST-AID KIT.
Do you feel like you're swimming against a strong current in your life? Are you fearful? Are you seeing red? Very angry? Anxious? Feel down or upset by everyday occurrences? Plagued by chronic discomforts like migraine headaches? Have seasickness on cruises? Have butterflies when you get up to speak? Learn to use this simple 21st Century memory technique. Remove these unwanted physical body states, and even more, without surgery, drugs, or psychotherapy, and best of all: without charge to you.
Simply CLICK AND OPEN the FIRST-AID KIT.